March
29th of 2009 saw the second international Earth Hour. All nations of
the world are invited to show solidarity with conservation efforts by
turning off unused house lights for an hour. I myself saved a couple of
pandas by turning off all of our lights (I'm usually pretty miserly
anyway, I don't keep superfluous bulbs burning). Earth Hour is a fine
gesture, but we need to be doing a lot more.
Over the past six months or so I have found ten TiVo DVRs thrown
out in Chicago alleys. I've never had a TiVo before (I couldn't warm up
to the notion of paying my VCR to record shows for me), so I took them
all home to see why they were dumped. After powering them up, I saw the
problem. These TiVos were all branded to work with a specific cable
satellite provider. Once the customer changed providers, the TiVo was suddenly
rendered useless.
I was alarmed by this because a TiVo is a sophisticated device.
These 10 units I found have plenty of life left in them, yet they were
all garbage. These TiVos suffer from being a nigh useless appliances without that specific satellite service and a subscription. I was surprised that I couldn't
at least use the TiVo like a programmable VCR.
So these expensive, functional, and technically capable devices
are now landfill. I was frankly
shocked at the wastefulness of the whole enterprise. My attitude
doesn't stem from the renewed focus on environmentalism or the need to
be financially responsible more than ever... the pitching of these
TiVos is simply abhorrent to me.
I detest when a device is retired prematurely, especially when it's
just all about marketing. This isn't good for the consumer nor good for
the planet. It's bad enough that this summer will see a profusion of
television sets (some estimates are as high as 99 million) in the
rubbish bin, but it looks like more and more TiVos will be rendered
useless because of limited forethought and selfish design.
In my dream world, the TiVo would have been designed with a
“simple” mode that would let you use it as a VCR-style recorder. I realize
that TiVo's business model relies on the subscriptions they collect, but
I still can't get past how wrong it is to create a device that is crippled purely for marketing reasons. Aim those RF “blaster”
thingies at a DTV tuner and you've got a perfect DVR for a second TV in
your house. Are these ideas so crazy, TiVo?
On a sociological note, I was amused at the programming still on
these TiVos. It was pretty easy to guess at the the family makeup by
the shows recorded on the TiVo's hard drive. Most of the decks were
pretty varied, but I did find a couple that were distinctly “his” and
“hers” units. I don't like to make broad generalizations like that, but
what else can I think when one TiVo had season passes for every morning
trash talk show & HGTV, while the other was choked with
professional wrestling and Headbanger's Ball (that's still on?!)?
Oh, and in case you're wondering... I did ameliorate the situation
at least a little bit. I removed the hard drives from each of the TiVos
and am using them in a variety of other devices. Let's just hope that
there are some pro-environment hackers that will find a way to squeeze
some extra performance out of these abandoned TiVos that will soon be
littering the alleys of the rest of the world.
related:
Philips N1500: Dawn of the Timeshifting Age
Looking Back Fondly At The First Video Format War
The World's First Commercial VCR